New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Dec 13, 2025 7:30 AM
#1
| Yuri's gender change is something to get used to. What a change though lol Jonas is someone that I didn't pay too much attention to at first but he did have his own agenda after all. Felt like a buildup episode |
Dec 13, 2025 7:55 AM
#2
| “It’s all your fault. My angel” Absolute banger of an episode. We finally got what we should’ve had all along, Yuri as a girl 🤣 I know they went with a non binary character for a reason, but man I really liked how different this loop was because of her being a girl. Changing genders changes the way people interact with you and the sides of themselves that they show you. For example, Yuri normally has this really flirtatious relationship with SQ where SQ teases her, but in this loop they felt more like siblings/best friends. She normally has a standoffish relationship with Sha-Ming, but I kinda shipped them today ngl lol. I can’t lie I got a little anxious in that kissing scene tho because I thought Shaming might actually try and fuck Yuri, but luckily Yuri is a good judge of character and he didn’t try anything. That ending was wild tho. One minute there’s a killer slime on the loose eating everyone, the next, it’s all smiles and optimism for there being at least ONE world line out there where everyone gets a happy ending. We were so close today, rip Remnan and Shigemichi 🥲 great episode, hopefully we get more episodes with some gender twists! |
Marinate1016Dec 13, 2025 5:12 PM
Dec 13, 2025 9:33 AM
#3
Reply to Marinate1016
“It’s all your fault. My angel” Absolute banger of an episode. We finally got what we should’ve had all along, Yuri as a girl 🤣 I know they went with a non binary character for a reason, but man I really liked how different this loop was because of her being a girl.
Changing genders changes the way people interact with you and the sides of themselves that they show you. For example, Yuri normally has this really flirtatious relationship with SQ where SQ teases her, but in this loop they felt more like siblings/best friends. She normally has a standoffish relationship with Sha-Ming, but I kinda shipped them today ngl lol.
I can’t lie I got a little anxious in that kissing scene tho because I thought Shaming might actually try and fuck Yuri, but luckily Yuri is a good judge of character and he didn’t try anything.
That ending was wild tho. One minute there’s a killer slime on the loose eating everyone, the next, it’s all smiles and optimism for there being at least ONE world line out there where everyone gets a happy ending. We were so close today, rip Remnan and Shigemichi 🥲 great episode, hopefully we get more episodes with some gender twists!
Changing genders changes the way people interact with you and the sides of themselves that they show you. For example, Yuri normally has this really flirtatious relationship with SQ where SQ teases her, but in this loop they felt more like siblings/best friends. She normally has a standoffish relationship with Sha-Ming, but I kinda shipped them today ngl lol.
I can’t lie I got a little anxious in that kissing scene tho because I thought Shaming might actually try and fuck Yuri, but luckily Yuri is a good judge of character and he didn’t try anything.
That ending was wild tho. One minute there’s a killer slime on the loose eating everyone, the next, it’s all smiles and optimism for there being at least ONE world line out there where everyone gets a happy ending. We were so close today, rip Remnan and Shigemichi 🥲 great episode, hopefully we get more episodes with some gender twists!
| @Marinate1016 It's 2 cour anime |
Dec 13, 2025 9:38 AM
#4
| Was this in the game or original? I don’t remember this(not that I complain) |
Dec 13, 2025 9:40 AM
#5
| Finally an episode where they took advantage of the anime format vs the game, they did it out a contrived plot twist by having "Comet going into cold sleep by accident" (how the hell can it even happen, it's ridiculous lol, they could have just fast forward a turn 1 vote on Comet) but that made for an interesting twist. Setsu's sacrifice is a bit on the ridiculous side in the way it's animated, not the first nor the last thing that looks really awkward when translated into an anime in this story though @talortoo : The gender change is original, the events aren't. (SQ/Remnan bullying, Slime when Comet is in cold sleep, the Sauna ending) The game allowed you to pick your gender but there was no switch in a playthrough (and the gender had next to 0 impact on the writing) |
Dec 13, 2025 9:47 AM
#6
| Sorry Gnosia Anime, I wasn't familiar with your game. The idea of the MC getting gender swapped upon shifting timeline to collect male-exclusive events is very creative, same scriptwriter as Steins;Gate so no wonder. This episode is also lore-packed, besides the slime incident, there're also that Racio shower scene, Remnan and SQ's secret, and Kukrushka's other body. Guess most people overlook this detail: SQ refers to herself as "SQ-chan" when she is human, meanwhile she uses the pronoun "atashi" every time being Gnosia. |
Dec 13, 2025 9:54 AM
#7
Fisico said: Finally an episode where they took advantage of the anime format vs the game, they did it out a contrived plot twist by having "Comet going into cold sleep by accident" (how the hell can it even happen, it's ridiculous lol, they could have just fast forward a turn 1 vote on Comet) but that made for an interesting twist. Setsu's sacrifice is a bit on the ridiculous side in the way it's animated, not the first nor the last thing that looks really awkward when translated into an anime in this story though @talortoo : The gender change is original, the events aren't. (SQ/Remnan bullying, Slime when Comet is in cold sleep, the Sauna ending) The game allowed you to pick your gender but there was no switch in a playthrough (and the gender had next to 0 impact on the writing) Ok tnx I forgot we even had the option to choose gender lol |
Dec 13, 2025 9:56 AM
#8
| Oooh Jonas is so sexy, I've to thank slime to make him shirtless! This anime always shake things up even if all rules are revealed. Despite all the twists, the most important change in this episode is gender change. Some people might ask "why gender play a role here when everyone, regardless of their gender or even species, are under the same rule?" And the answer is "yes, gender definitely play a role here, quite a big one really" Yuri now feel "unsafe" to talk to Shigemichi because of "male gaze" even though Shigemichi is confirmed to be human. And Yuri might gather some information, or even save Shigemichi from the slime if Yuri decide to talk to him. But being a female also has its upside, Yuri now can talk heart-to-heart with Sha-ming, who only open his heart to woman. New opportunities, new risks, this anime doesn't say it out loud how gender play a role because it's afraid to be seen as woke media, so it's my duty to say it. |
Dec 13, 2025 10:04 AM
#9
Dec 13, 2025 10:12 AM
#10
| a sex change loop, interesting. |
Dec 13, 2025 10:40 AM
#11
| I really detest how the anime is handling the Yuri/Setsu relationship. This should be the heart of the anime, yet their interactions are constantly like two people who only just met. Every time Yuri wakes up and Setsu is there they talk like what Yuri's saying is weird, despite Setsu knowing precisely what is happening. It's just baffling to me, especially when it should be thing that ties the loops together. By making it so standoffish they've lost a key part of the game without seemingly gaining anything. I thought it was starting that way so they could slow the arc of them bonding, but we're almost half-way and they've done nothing. I wouldn't have minded the slime being more visceral as well. Unlike the Kukrushka episode, they didn't go any further than the game here and that feels like a waste. The change in Yuri's perspective with their gender change was interesting, precisely because it's the kind of thing the game doesn't (and can't) do. I wish they'd gone all in on that. Really, that's kind of my theme with this anime so far, I wish it would commit more to doing and showing the things that the game can't. |
QuitchDec 13, 2025 2:21 PM
Dec 13, 2025 10:44 AM
#12
| Gender bend is always peak, great director, anime using it's strength properly... The comet thing baffles me, a lot of lore drop, kukuruska should then always e one the ship if jonas is there and she is not, setsu sacrifice, sq's papa is renman???, it was so funny that couldn't help but love it... |
InternetAngelAmeDec 13, 2025 11:22 AM
Dec 13, 2025 10:52 AM
#13
| Didn't mind the gender swap, but the giant slime mold? That was a bit much! LOL Still a fun episode though. |
Dec 13, 2025 11:10 AM
#14
talortoo said: Was this in the game or original? I don’t remember this(not that I complain) Nope , there wasn't an event about gender bender. In the game if you choose male protagonist you play as male until the end. I think this is a good change. In the game they are exclusive events for male and female versions of the protagonist. In anime you can now have both just changing Yuri sex. |
Dec 13, 2025 11:18 AM
#15
| I kind of assumed Yuri was genderless until this point, like Setsu and Racio, to get over how this is an original character in a game where you can select your gender, but I guess he was... well, a he. Pretty good episode. I like how, after the initial batch of episodes gradually explaining the rules, the show mixes things up to keep the formula interesting. |
Dec 13, 2025 11:35 AM
#17
| Banger episode, I like how we are getting more into the lore of the characters and the different endings now that we have gone through many episodes of the actual game. What's confusing to me is why did Comet's slime go out of control? The other times she was put into cold sleep, the slime did not react like that. I also agree with @Quitch that the Setsu relationship is weird. The basis of them not talking to each other about the loops was that they "both could be Gnosia". I can understand that, you see Yuri talking to Racio because he is a confirmed human. But then... Yuri reveals to Sha-Ming about the loops even though Yuri knows that he's a Gnosia?? The only reason I could see Setsu saying Yuri "must be still confused" at the beginning is because she must have seen Yuri as a female in another loop but doesn't want to divulge that information? Or else I can't quite understand why she would still be acting that way now that they both always know they're looping together. I really liked the gender swap, it shows how differently things can go depending on one's gender. Shigemichi doing his chad face will never not be funny LMAO! Loving this series, can't wait for next week. |
Dec 13, 2025 11:43 AM
#18
CukieMunster said: Banger episode, I like how we are getting more into the lore of the characters and the different endings now that we have gone through many episodes of the actual game. What's confusing to me is why did Comet's slime go out of control? The other times she was put into cold sleep, the slime did not react like that. I also agree with @Quitch that the Setsu relationship is weird. The basis of them not talking to each other about the loops was that they "both could be Gnosia". I can understand that, you see Yuri talking to Racio because he is a confirmed human. But then... Yuri reveals to Sha-Ming about the loops even though Yuri knows that he's a Gnosia?? The only reason I could see Setsu saying Yuri "must be still confused" at the beginning is because she must have seen Yuri as a female in another loop but doesn't want to divulge that information? Or else I can't quite understand why she would still be acting that way now that they both always know they're looping together. I really liked the gender swap, it shows how differently things can go depending on one's gender. Shigemichi doing his chad face will never not be funny LMAO! Loving this series, can't wait for next week. Comet is a biological weapon. Cold makes slime grow and never before Comet wasn't put in cold sleep and taken away. Slime was 'thinking' Comet died and started attacking everything. EDIT : So yeah. Cold sleep is a death sentence for her because you can't open her without risk. |
Dec 13, 2025 11:47 AM
#19
Reply to CukieMunster
Banger episode, I like how we are getting more into the lore of the characters and the different endings now that we have gone through many episodes of the actual game.
What's confusing to me is why did Comet's slime go out of control? The other times she was put into cold sleep, the slime did not react like that.
I also agree with @Quitch that the Setsu relationship is weird. The basis of them not talking to each other about the loops was that they "both could be Gnosia". I can understand that, you see Yuri talking to Racio because he is a confirmed human. But then... Yuri reveals to Sha-Ming about the loops even though Yuri knows that he's a Gnosia??
The only reason I could see Setsu saying Yuri "must be still confused" at the beginning is because she must have seen Yuri as a female in another loop but doesn't want to divulge that information? Or else I can't quite understand why she would still be acting that way now that they both always know they're looping together.
I really liked the gender swap, it shows how differently things can go depending on one's gender. Shigemichi doing his chad face will never not be funny LMAO!
Loving this series, can't wait for next week.
What's confusing to me is why did Comet's slime go out of control? The other times she was put into cold sleep, the slime did not react like that.
I also agree with @Quitch that the Setsu relationship is weird. The basis of them not talking to each other about the loops was that they "both could be Gnosia". I can understand that, you see Yuri talking to Racio because he is a confirmed human. But then... Yuri reveals to Sha-Ming about the loops even though Yuri knows that he's a Gnosia??
The only reason I could see Setsu saying Yuri "must be still confused" at the beginning is because she must have seen Yuri as a female in another loop but doesn't want to divulge that information? Or else I can't quite understand why she would still be acting that way now that they both always know they're looping together.
I really liked the gender swap, it shows how differently things can go depending on one's gender. Shigemichi doing his chad face will never not be funny LMAO!
Loving this series, can't wait for next week.
| @CukieMunster CukieMunster said: What's confusing to me is why did Comet's slime go out of control? The other times she was put into cold sleep, the slime did not react like that. That's cuz she was taken out of cold sleep by Jonas and I guess the slime woke up first. |
| You are not your body, you are your brain, the "self" that emerges from within it. |
Dec 13, 2025 12:02 PM
#21
| woah woah woah. a female Yuri in another loop? now I did NOT see that coming but I welcome it! 😂😂✌🏾 nigga, freak Sha-ming. 😭👍🏾 why tf bro gotta say all of that to Yuri? I can only see Yuri as a guy so him saying all of that be making me feel weird but it's hilarious. 😭🙏🏾 but I kinda get his character now. and I can't hate him if that's his mindset. an interesting guy ngl. that little scene with female Yuri and Sha-ming was actually pretty wholesome but yea, I see Yuri as a guy so I had to hold myself during that scene. still good though. another banger episode and I got to see the truth about Jonas's late lover and Kukrushka having...two bodies? enjoyed it. iirc, this is 2 cours so that's a W. |
Dec 13, 2025 12:18 PM
#22
| Shaming gotta be the best guy in this series. And damn i wasn't expecting that type of ending lol, nice to see some good endings. |
Dec 13, 2025 12:40 PM
#23
| How come Comet entered cold sleep "accidentally"? o.O |
| TOP DEBUTS OF THE 2025 Q4 SEASON: 1) Tojima Wants to Be a Kamen Rider 2) May I Ask for One Final Thing? 3) A Wild Last Boss Appeared! 4) Dusk Beyond the End of the World 5) Gnosia |
Dec 13, 2025 12:57 PM
#24
Reply to Rafael2AMerlo
How come Comet entered cold sleep "accidentally"? o.O

| @Rafael2AMerlo It's Comet. If you still haven't noticed, both her and Shigemichi are idiots. |
Dec 13, 2025 1:33 PM
#25
Reply to thewiru
thewiru said: If you still haven't noticed, both her and Shigemichi are idiots. It's Comet as Gnosia |
Dec 13, 2025 2:26 PM
#26
Reply to talortoo
Was this in the game or original? I don’t remember this(not that I complain)
| SQ forgot to comment on Racio's anatomy in the shower, as she does in the game. Racio is male. talortoo said: Was this in the game or original? I don’t remember this(not that I complain) The scene in Sha-Ming's room is new. I don't like it much. |
| その目だれの目? |
Dec 13, 2025 2:28 PM
#27
| Racio gender reveal let's go |
Dec 13, 2025 2:41 PM
#28
Dec 13, 2025 3:17 PM
#30
| Of course the big break from the script this time had to be from Comet being Comet. Bless her soul. The fact Sha-Ming managed to earn Yuri's faith in his character beyond loops and Gnosia infections is beautiful. It's like knowing the werewolf/mafia player who loves to trashtalk is a good dude outside of the game. |
Dec 13, 2025 3:35 PM
#31
| Sha-ming proves he's the best character in the show, yet another time. |
Dec 13, 2025 3:39 PM
#32
| I saw some people mention it's cool they're "shaking up the rules" but they're not shaking them up they're just ignoring or changing them entirely with no explanation of why. What started as strict rules have turned to suggestions which feels cheap. And why is Yuri now just talking about looping with everyone? I had to make sure I didn't skip an episode because it's so random. And as another said the fact Setsu and Yuri are supposed to be gathering info but don't consistently work together seems like a waste. |
Dec 13, 2025 3:50 PM
#33
Reply to WestOnAndrewAve
I saw some people mention it's cool they're "shaking up the rules" but they're not shaking them up they're just ignoring or changing them entirely with no explanation of why. What started as strict rules have turned to suggestions which feels cheap. And why is Yuri now just talking about looping with everyone? I had to make sure I didn't skip an episode because it's so random. And as another said the fact Setsu and Yuri are supposed to be gathering info but don't consistently work together seems like a waste.
WestOnAndrewAve said: And why is Yuri now just talking about looping with everyone? I had to make sure I didn't skip an episode because it's so random. The player talks about looping in the game too. I don't see why (s)he wouldn't. |
| その目だれの目? |
Dec 13, 2025 4:23 PM
#34
Lucifrost said: WestOnAndrewAve said: And why is Yuri now just talking about looping with everyone? I had to make sure I didn't skip an episode because it's so random. The player talks about looping in the game too. I don't see why (s)he wouldn't. Because they acted like it was some big secret until now with no mention of it to anyone not involved. I'd be open to it if it was led up to at all but it just blatantly cut to the end of the discussion with someone who has only antagonized Yuri to this point and then casually dropped it during other discussions with another character like they already knew this info. This show does a lot of that specifically where it skips the explaining to make room for a scene it wants to show but leaves holes all over the place. Edit: Forgot about the previous Raquio conversation in Eps. 2 |
WestOnAndrewAveDec 13, 2025 5:19 PM
Dec 13, 2025 4:56 PM
#35
Reply to WestOnAndrewAve
Lucifrost said:
The player talks about looping in the game too. I don't see why (s)he wouldn't.
WestOnAndrewAve said:
And why is Yuri now just talking about looping with everyone? I had to make sure I didn't skip an episode because it's so random.
And why is Yuri now just talking about looping with everyone? I had to make sure I didn't skip an episode because it's so random.
The player talks about looping in the game too. I don't see why (s)he wouldn't.
Because they acted like it was some big secret until now with no mention of it to anyone not involved. I'd be open to it if it was led up to at all but it just blatantly cut to the end of the discussion with someone who has only antagonized Yuri to this point and then casually dropped it during other discussions with another character like they already knew this info. This show does a lot of that specifically where it skips the explaining to make room for a scene it wants to show but leaves holes all over the place.
Edit: Forgot about the previous Raquio conversation in Eps. 2
| @WestOnAndrewAve Dude. Yuri confided in Raqio in episode 2 and got some very useful knowledge out of it. Raqio is aware of the existence of organisms like the Silver Key, so talking to him about it is easy. |
| You are not your body, you are your brain, the "self" that emerges from within it. |
Dec 13, 2025 5:18 PM
#36
HyperL said: @WestOnAndrewAve Dude. Yuri confided in Raqio in episode 2 and got some very useful knowledge out of it. Raqio is aware of the existence of organisms like the Silver Key, so talking to him about it is easy. You're right I did forget about that conversation. Which also just makes it more confusing why he hasn't talked to Raqio or anyone else about it since. |
Dec 13, 2025 8:12 PM
#37
| this is getting really boooooooooring I haven't seen epic plays in either roles, Yuuri is so boring, Setsu is also boring |
Haunt88Dec 14, 2025 3:38 AM
Dec 13, 2025 10:27 PM
#38
Shadow_Master_T said: I kind of assumed Yuri was genderless until this point I kind of really don't like that the implication of this episode is that Yuri being female is new. I really liked that the series never gave any info on their gender; it was unique for the MC. They could have just had them be confused about the increased bust size and higher pitched voice and still kept them as an ambiguous gender for their normal loops, but this really did imply that they're normally not a woman. |
Dec 13, 2025 10:29 PM
#39
certifiedbinger said: Sha-ming proves he's the best character in the show, yet another time. You are my people. I adore Sha-ming so much. |
Dec 13, 2025 11:00 PM
#40
| Given the name, voice, and overall look of the character (plus the show focussing on gender a bunch) I was kinda expecting this from the beginning (actually though he was a girl at the beginning). Didn't really add anything unfortunately, no real tension with Sha-ming since we already went through that loop. Only question is how are dolls getting infected with Gnosia? I see Crunchyroll already has this listed for next season too. Not sure I can watch another season of this. |
Dec 14, 2025 12:47 AM
#42
Reply to WestOnAndrewAve
HyperL said:
@WestOnAndrewAve Dude. Yuri confided in Raqio in episode 2 and got some very useful knowledge out of it. Raqio is aware of the existence of organisms like the Silver Key, so talking to him about it is easy.
@WestOnAndrewAve Dude. Yuri confided in Raqio in episode 2 and got some very useful knowledge out of it. Raqio is aware of the existence of organisms like the Silver Key, so talking to him about it is easy.
You're right I did forget about that conversation. Which also just makes it more confusing why he hasn't talked to Raqio or anyone else about it since.
| @WestOnAndrewAve because this time around it was confirmed raqio wasn't a gnosia and that was confirmed because of guard duty... Raqio is a self serving monarch most of the time and as a gnosia he would make use of the information and exploit it, so it's better to share information when it's confirmed, setsu shared information when she was the gnosia, because she knew yuri wasn't... Each character except setsu and yuri have single world line, so they would use these knowledge to exploit the situation, so it makes sense why yuri would tell people something some time around (because trust and safety is needed) and not the other time (because the main goal is surviving as long as possible, sometime even the mc has to decieve people, so people with information has the power, so losing it is a huge risk, but sharing it would be a huge help, with confirmed human's) and also it is made respectful to the game players like the kamen rider anime is made to it's og fans, so some refrences wouldn't get through us, but would get through only the game players, as a love letter to them, so that's kinda annoying but game players explain that in the forums, so that's great... |
InternetAngelAmeDec 14, 2025 12:58 AM
Dec 14, 2025 12:50 AM
#43
| Babes, all of you try this show needs you to remember each and every dialogue to make sense, each dialogue is essential, so don't get annoyed, because on forums e will remind you why everything makes sense, everything that happens is essential, because 1) time travel 2) death game... 3) Made by indie developers |
Dec 14, 2025 4:18 AM
#44
| The games themselves are getting a bit repetitive, which I'm glad they are being glazed over more often, but the clear shift to world-building and a "bigger picture" are keeping me interested. I'm (perhaps delusionally) hoping that this is "false narrative" storytelling which would tie into the original premise of the show as well. |
Dec 14, 2025 8:12 AM
#45
| One thing that bothered me all day, does the episode end on a note that everyone is alive???? |
Dec 14, 2025 8:15 AM
#46
Reply to MenchiK1
Given the name, voice, and overall look of the character (plus the show focussing on gender a bunch) I was kinda expecting this from the beginning (actually though he was a girl at the beginning). Didn't really add anything unfortunately, no real tension with Sha-ming since we already went through that loop. Only question is how are dolls getting infected with Gnosia? I see Crunchyroll already has this listed for next season too. Not sure I can watch another season of this.
MenchiK1 said: Only question is how are dolls getting infected with Gnosia? We already established in episode 7 that AI can be Gnosia. |
| その目だれの目? |
Dec 14, 2025 8:25 AM
#47
-_-NyxCiara-_- said: @WestOnAndrewAve because this time around it was confirmed raqio wasn't a gnosia and that was confirmed because of guard duty... Raqio is a self serving monarch most of the time and as a gnosia he would make use of the information and exploit it, so it's better to share information when it's confirmed, setsu shared information when she was the gnosia, because she knew yuri wasn't... Each character except setsu and yuri have single world line, so they would use these knowledge to exploit the situation, so it makes sense why yuri would tell people something some time around (because trust and safety is needed) and not the other time (because the main goal is surviving as long as possible, sometime even the mc has to decieve people, so people with information has the power, so losing it is a huge risk, but sharing it would be a huge help, with confirmed human's) and also it is made respectful to the game players like the kamen rider anime is made to it's og fans, so some refrences wouldn't get through us, but would get through only the game players, as a love letter to them, so that's kinda annoying but game players explain that in the forums, so that's great... I understand why he would tell some and not others once they're proven safe, I'm saying it's weird he doesn't do it more often so this felt like it came out of knowwhere, especially when he knew one was a Gnosia. So him sharing has nothing to do with Gnosia or not. And only sharing info when Setsu or Yuri is confirmed Gnosia is also weird because they would be enemies with different purposes, it makes sense to share info all the time if anything. Unless they do but we're just not shown it everytime. Honoring game players isn't a problem and in fact is a great thing to do, but it should stand on it's own as well. And that's where the explanations for things that happen have been lacking. There's also some problems to be expected when translating game mechanics that are given a pass because it's a game into a story that needs some sort of explained structure. But instead of explaining it in a way that both makes sense and is consistent, it just chooses not to. And it's nothing to do with the time travel because that's actually pretty simple. But the limits and rules of each "run" keep allowing for variations that just shouldn't be. |
Dec 14, 2025 9:20 AM
#48
| When Jonas entered the room at the end, I expected another creepy ending. Glad to see it turned out comedic instead. What's up with Remnan? He ran away from some abusive woman, I get that. But why do every other woman wants to bully him? Kukrushka, a doll, murdered everyone for him. Now SQ was up to something. Wtf. |
Dec 14, 2025 9:58 AM
#49
Reply to WestOnAndrewAve
-_-NyxCiara-_- said:
@WestOnAndrewAve because this time around it was confirmed raqio wasn't a gnosia and that was confirmed because of guard duty...
Raqio is a self serving monarch most of the time and as a gnosia he would make use of the information and exploit it, so it's better to share information when it's confirmed, setsu shared information when she was the gnosia, because she knew yuri wasn't... Each character except setsu and yuri have single world line, so they would use these knowledge to exploit the situation, so it makes sense why yuri would tell people something some time around (because trust and safety is needed) and not the other time (because the main goal is surviving as long as possible, sometime even the mc has to decieve people, so people with information has the power, so losing it is a huge risk, but sharing it would be a huge help, with confirmed human's) and also it is made respectful to the game players like the kamen rider anime is made to it's og fans, so some refrences wouldn't get through us, but would get through only the game players, as a love letter to them, so that's kinda annoying but game players explain that in the forums, so that's great...
@WestOnAndrewAve because this time around it was confirmed raqio wasn't a gnosia and that was confirmed because of guard duty...
Raqio is a self serving monarch most of the time and as a gnosia he would make use of the information and exploit it, so it's better to share information when it's confirmed, setsu shared information when she was the gnosia, because she knew yuri wasn't... Each character except setsu and yuri have single world line, so they would use these knowledge to exploit the situation, so it makes sense why yuri would tell people something some time around (because trust and safety is needed) and not the other time (because the main goal is surviving as long as possible, sometime even the mc has to decieve people, so people with information has the power, so losing it is a huge risk, but sharing it would be a huge help, with confirmed human's) and also it is made respectful to the game players like the kamen rider anime is made to it's og fans, so some refrences wouldn't get through us, but would get through only the game players, as a love letter to them, so that's kinda annoying but game players explain that in the forums, so that's great...
I understand why he would tell some and not others once they're proven safe, I'm saying it's weird he doesn't do it more often so this felt like it came out of knowwhere, especially when he knew one was a Gnosia. So him sharing has nothing to do with Gnosia or not. And only sharing info when Setsu or Yuri is confirmed Gnosia is also weird because they would be enemies with different purposes, it makes sense to share info all the time if anything. Unless they do but we're just not shown it everytime.
Honoring game players isn't a problem and in fact is a great thing to do, but it should stand on it's own as well. And that's where the explanations for things that happen have been lacking. There's also some problems to be expected when translating game mechanics that are given a pass because it's a game into a story that needs some sort of explained structure. But instead of explaining it in a way that both makes sense and is consistent, it just chooses not to. And it's nothing to do with the time travel because that's actually pretty simple. But the limits and rules of each "run" keep allowing for variations that just shouldn't be.
| @WestOnAndrewAve He shares it with people at end so that he (she this time) ca help them develop and see it happen to see happen, to fill up the silver key... Let me start of with facts:- Shaming, Jina & Stella are the kindest, Yuriko & Racio are the smartest, Comet & Shigemichi are the dumbest, SQ & Kukurushka are the most mysterious... He told it to stella to make her realize she is human... She told is to Sha-ming to make him realize that him accept that he's a sheep in wolf's clothing and Yuri wasn't the only one acting tough... He told it to Racio because they're smart event to stand offish and they'd be a great ally in a situation when it's confirmed they're not gnosia... I'm saying it's weird he doesn't do it more often so this felt like it came out of nowhere, especially when he knew one was a Gnosia. He needs to do as much info as he can in one timeline, Sha-ming doesn't really wanna kill anyone and would straight up send himself to cold sleep, so it was reasonable enough to tell him, because Sha-ming wouldn't betray a gal even as a gnosia (as we know don't loose their personality) especially one who trusted him... Reasons to trust and not trust gnosia cast, i won't go on every character because it'd take time to type, if you want I can send it to you personally, because there are many more reasons and a lot of people don't like analysis, I have remembered every freaking detail, as far as we've seen: Sha-ming: Can be trusted as a gal, because he doesn't wanna betray either of the two sides, ecause he doesn't wanna kill humans or get the gnosia killed who were human, but he is (Afraid?) to confess he is one but tries his best to get voted out, can be trusted as a girl... Jina: She is pretty determined to survive even though she is the 2nd worst to lying after Comet, She is afraid of dying by gnosia's hand, telling her things wouldn't be beneficial at all, till her back story if revealed... Comet: No benefit in telling her the secret, She is pretty determined to survive, after all the hardships she has been through she would do anything to survive and achieve her dreams, Even though she wouldn't last at all as a Gnosia, We can share our secret with her but she wouldn't be able to convice people except if Racio walks in... Kukurushka, SQ, Yuriko, Racio: Too suspicious, They will use our knoweldge against us in the game as an Gnosia but they seem pretty determined in surving and care barely or not at all about the rest of the cast, Or one of them would straight up kill us on confrontation... Jonas, Shigemichi: Tell me one benefit of telling them??? One has gone mad due to using cold sleep multiple time, One is only interested in Women and as a gnosia always ends up being Racio's partner, so couldn't be trusted or is useless to share info... Sharing all the info could lead to multiple things: If racio or setsu isn't there, there is no one to confirm the facts... If we share this on the first day, It's quite unbelievable and risk getting voted one when the main goal is survival over victory... If one of the people who can confirm the fact are the gnosia, they'd deny it and use the intellect to frame us into everyone's suspicion (Setsu would never) Not everyone's intellect is on par with Racio Or Yuriko, So like Sha-ming many people wouldn't want to believe it, Or I elieve many like Comet or Shigemichi wouldn't even know about such thing leading them to believe its a lie (Comet wouldnt because she can see through them, but it is also confirmed that she and yuri also can only see through people who are bad at lying, Jina/Comet/Shigemich/Yuri, HE couldn't detect the lie of Stella in the 3rd Episode and it's not a strech to make becuase in the previous episode Comet say's that Yuri bad at lying, which could imply she could also se only through weak liar's), because it's better to believe what you want to for most then what actually is the truth... It wouldn't add much to the meeting because we could easily lie about a character acting different, because for god's sake there's no confirmation that We aren't be the gnosia, even decreasing people's trust in us furthermore, because Time travel for an person who lacks there meomory is a convinent lie to gain autority of the discussion, many people wouldn't like people taking charge in the discussion, many times Setsu has been the eye of suspicion because of them being the narrator or the moderator of the meetings...They get randomly voted when no one is suspicious... I haven't even added other roles relevance in this, A gnosia Engineer would claim us to be the Gnosia further susing us out infront the crew, because people would be already suspicious of us, many like Jina would prefer to follow the crowd and do whatever they does... Setsu wants Yuri to give his best, but sharing information when they are the gnosia is the best move because they're aware of the time loops and the "silver key," realizing that sharing information and working with the Gnosia (even when Setsu is Gnosia) helps fill the key with knowledge, which is the only way to break the loop and progress towards a true ending, prioritizing this goal over simple crew vs. Gnosia conflict. It's a strategic move within the looping reality, leveraging their unique knowledge to gain understanding, even if it means revealing their hidden nature to the player. They are curious of what would Yuri do in such a situation... Like Setsu said, This is the only worldline for the rest of the crew beside Yuri and setsu, so it'd be better to priortise their lives over there time looped bond friendship, Yuri helped comet even though he had to kill setsu in that one loop because that would be better for the People of that particular timeline... Yuri is a more emotional person, because after he betrayed Stella in the Setsu gnosia route, he asked Setsu to kill him, so he wouldn't want to be put up in a situation ever again where he'd have to choose between Setsu or one of the crew, because it's hard to kill a friend, even if it's only temporary, I believe in the Comet ending Yuri killed Yuriko (conflict for name) and Comet killed Setsu... Or timrlines are not flowing linearly so she'd have seen a different version of Yuri that we might have not even seen, so trusting Yuri would be harder for her too, because She's have seen Yuri do some sh!t too under certain influence... I feel as if I'm cracking the code, because Setsu in her reveal Gnosia timeline had done over 100 loops, She could've have seen a 1000 loop Yuri who'd had lost his mind, went on a Kukurushka event excursion Or even lost use for Setsu so he'd do sh!t to gain knowledge even if he is ruining the life of all those in that particular time Setsu once experienced... I'm a child who has been said to have much more on the imagination side so I made things click for me by connecting things I've seen in other shows or Indie games with the information I had gathered in this show... Still some questions are yet to be answered... Why do Gnosia KILL, is it due to instinct or Is it some plot twist??? What are the other sources of danger that are more terrifying then Gnosia, that even they run away from it... Yuri has been slowly improving his stats and knoweledge, so early on he'd wanna share it all over, Jina used that against him by acting as if she believed him, later he became cautious, now he's sharing according to the situation and person as per the circumstances... Honoring game players isn't a problem and in fact is a great thing to do, but it should stand on it's own as well. And that's where the explanations for things that happen have been lacking. Sha-ming has the game skill to grovel which is here used for comedy purpose, he can just prevent himself for getting voted out, proving that he is actually sacred of being voted out as mentioned as a theory above even though he wants to keep everyone safe as per the crew memebers he'd decide to shut his room or not as per the Gnosia The Jonas Vs. Shigemichi game is used to determine who's the gnosia among themand whoever is the winner reveals his secret, this was used for comedy purposely and that being used reputedly would get annoying, so there's no point in revealing it, but I would like to know that because i'm curious but adding everything too the plot would make it mundane little repetitive mess... Comet's and Yuri's Lie detecting skill was made apparent...because it was necessary... Yuriko word's when a decision is not made are used to vote someone out is well established, but isn't much used, because a suspect or two or four are always there, her skill's used when no suspects or suspicious person is already around, because she likes to give less effort in the meetings because they're a bother to her and she wants to get done with it, so her skill is necessary to make the cast decide unless they take a break in situation like Sha-ming's shut his room up event... These thing's would be better noticed by player's but can still be experienced by us even though just for a brief moment because keeping things fresh is the formula for Gnosia Anime to satisfy it's younger and older audience + What are essential to the game's mechanic is made pretty noticeable in Anime, Like the core themes and Lie detectors, A good show balances between it's audience and satisfies all of them but it's isn't a masterpiece by a long shot, it's upon the viewer to help each other understand through kinship, So correct me where I'm wrong... Hope that answers all and more of your query's because I see no plot holes yet, The only things that are not explained are what'd be the big reveal, If you still have queries ask them and I'd reply within 24 hours if I can that is because this show like many other isn't perfect and a plot hole might e resent that I glossed over while fangirling or it didn't bother me enough, YK!!!... |
InternetAngelAmeDec 14, 2025 11:05 AM
Dec 14, 2025 10:27 AM
#50
| @-_-NyxCiara-_- I love this anime, but it's not perfect, and your misunderstandings highlight the shortcomings of this adaptation. There are 2 things you've gotten completely wrong through no fault of your own. 1. The Gnosia want to kill, no exceptions. Even the Gnosia who give themselves up do it for other reasons. In this episode, for example, everyone Sha-Ming would have killed had already been killed by slime. 2. Sha-Ming has crazy defensive stats and is among the characters LEAST likely to be voted into cold sleep (e.g. groveling), even though he is annoying and Setsu hates him. The anime is trying way too hard to turn him into a good guy. Setsu threatens to kill Sha-Ming if he doesn't let himself out of his room. Setsu sometimes even carries out this threat, forcing the player to go through entire loops without Sha-Ming! But you seem to understand the pros and cons of sharing the secret of the Silver Key. As the anime has shown, there are basically 2 instances in which the protagonist talks to non-loopers about loops. 1. The Gnosia hunt has ended, and the protagonist has formed a bond with one of the survivors. 2. Someone has information crucial to solving the mystery, and shares it in exchange for the protagonist's knowledge on loops. We've seen this with Racio. |
| その目だれの目? |
More topics from this board
» Gnosia anime feels FAKE and there is a reason for thatgamibo - Aug 16 |
9 |
by Lucifrost
»»
Aug 23, 11:56 AM |
|
Poll: » Gnosia Episode 12 DiscussionStark700 - Dec 27, 2025 |
44 |
by Assassin2112
»»
Aug 11, 5:15 PM |
|
Poll: » Gnosia Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Dec 20, 2025 |
57 |
by Drakath_V
»»
Jul 29, 4:57 AM |
|
Poll: » Gnosia Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Dec 6, 2025 |
60 |
by Drakath_V
»»
Jul 29, 4:47 AM |
|
Poll: » Gnosia Episode 21 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Mar 14 |
87 |
by tanerl
»»
Jun 22, 3:56 PM |

